Somebody has integrity

The Reformed doctrine of man’s total depravity effectively denies the possibility of anyone acting with integrity because in the first place (they say) nothing we do is so truly good as to be free of the taint of sin, and in the second place everyone sins, and in the third place even the mildest of sins is worthy of infinite punishment. How then can there be anyone who acts with genuine integrity? The notion implies that this is a consistent, habitual aspect of such a man’s character, but that’s precisely the sort of thing that is ruled out by total depravity.

It is not ruled out by the Bible, however.

You guide those who act with integrity and keep your ways in mind (Isaiah 64:4a, JB).

Those who insist upon the idea of man’s total depravity have difficulties with passages like this, but this verse and others similar to it are perfectly consistent with the Catholic Faith. We are (with God’s help) able to act with integrity and to keep His ways in mind. We are not incapable of habitual integrity; we are not enslaved by sin to such a degree that we cannot do any good at all. It is true that we cannot save ourselves, but the Church has never suggested that we can do so.

If the Reformed were correct, then it seems that consistency would require them to deny that anyone acts with integrity. Their appeal to Romans 3 in defense of their view does not leave them much wiggle room for saying otherwise. But if no one acts with integrity, then Isaiah’s declaration is reduced to mere rhetoric; he would be saying it about nobody at all because nobody would fit the definition.

Tagged with: , ,
Posted in Apologetics, Sin
2 comments on “Somebody has integrity
  1. Robert says:

    Fred, we are not perfect therefore falling short of God’s standard hence the need for a Saviour. Anything short of that denies the efficacy of Christ’s sacrifice.

  2. aquinasetc says:

    Hi Robert,

    Integrity doesn’t require perfection. But those Reformed who deny that anyone does any good at all (and they are out there) deny that anyone has integrity at all. It is this which is in contradiction with the passage I quoted.

    Also, I said with God’s help we are able to act with integrity.

    But even if we were able to keep God’s law perfectly, we could not merit heaven at all. It is a supernatural end, and hence by very definition is completely and utterly beyond the scope of our natural powers. That is why we need grace: only by the grace of God can we ever hope to see His face.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 146 other subscribers
%d bloggers like this: